Is Leadership A Learned Discipline?

Posted

in

by

on

I recently read Plutarch’s argument for virtue needing to be taught, whilst everyone assumes it just comes about. He made a smaller point about everyone wanting to be a general but no-one wanting to study how to be one, assuming it just comes with certain accolades and experiences as a soldier. This had me thinking about leadership.

Want to be a maths teacher? You have to be learned in mathematics. Want to litigate a case at court? You have to pass the bar. Want to dance at the Bolshoi? You will have to spend your childhood training at its academy. Yet leadership is a position one often finds themselves in without such training.

Almost everyone performs the task and responsibility of leadership somewhere, some in the capacity of a parent, some as a teacher, others in business, in church or in a sports team. The list goes on.

This article’s purpose is to look at how good leaders come about. I won’t attempt to define what good leadership looks like in full. That is your opinion. For the question at hand, however, at least some level of definition is needed. Leadership is moving people towards a shared end. Good leadership is doing so for their benefit, rather than that of the leader. In Politics, Aristotle drew that line, Jesus did in the Bible, Simon Sinek in his book Leaders Eat Last.

That small definition asks for three things of anyone who would want to lead well according to it. You must know what is good for your people, you must be able to act on it and you must get there effectively, that is, against resistance. To the question of where those three abilities come from, history holds three answers for us. Leaders are made. Leaders are born. Leaders are given.

Leaders are Made

Knowing what your people need

For nearly a century, Rome’s emperors chose their heirs by adoption rather than birth, and groomed them for the job. When he was 16 years old, Marcus Aurelius was adopted by Emperor Antoninus Pius and spent twenty-three years at his side. One biographer says Aurelius only slept away from Antoninus’ house twice in all the time. Antoninus heard petitioners patiently and weighed their matters before deciding. Aurelius wrote that Antoninus listened to anyone with something to offer the common good. When Marcus Aurelius came to write for himself in his later years, he opened with a list of the people who had taught him and what they had given him.

To a more recent example, Winston Churchill was a poor student. He failed the Sandhurst entrance twice, and left Harrow close to the bottom of his class. His education began at twenty-two in Bangalore, where I am writing this article, as a cavalry officer with long afternoons to fill. Churchill read Plato, Schopenhauer, Macaulay and Gibbon (the latter wrote of how Rome groomed Marcus Aurelius). His mother sent him volumes of the Annual Register, containing condensed political history with every major debate summarised. He studied them and wrote his own verdict in the margin of the volumes, building what he called a scaffolding of logical and consistent views. He did this before ever speaking in Parliament.

The discipline to act on it

There are a great many ways how one might strengthen the will to act upon conviction. However, it is, of course, a pre-condition that one has developed a conviction whilst studying in the first place. For Churchill, building discipline took the form of seeking out combat. He was deeply driven by a conscious, perhaps an obsessive, desire to test his own courage and find out if he could bravely act under fire. During his military leave he used family connections to become an observer during the Cuban War of Independence in 1895, writing on the tactics of the Spanish (Churchill, 1930, chs. 6 to 7). Using connections once more, he was transferred to the frontier during a military mission in Malakand (Churchill, 1898) and rode in a cavalry charge in Omdurman. All before age 24 (My Early Life & The River War).

Marcus Aurelius deliberately trained himself in obedience and discipline, viewing them as daily practices of self-mastery, not innate traits. The Historia Augusta records that Aurelius chose to obey more the more power he had. Given tribunician power and proconsular imperium in 147, he essentially held the constitutional powers an emperor’s authority rested on. However, far from supplanting Antoninus Pius, he chose to serve for fourteen more years, putting discipline and obedience before self-gain. He reinforced this self-restraint through specific exercises, such as holding himself accountable through daily journaling and practising premeditatio malorum (the premeditation of adversity) to mentally practise handling power with humility. He rejected court luxuries, deliberately adopted a minimalist lifestyle, and constantly reframed his status as mere vanity, thereby ensuring that his growing authority never compromised his duty to the state.

Getting there effectively

The leader has now learned about his people and developed discipline to act upon his conviction. What is left is the actual ability to lead strategically, wisely and effectively, not in theory but in practice.

Churchill spent forty years in Parliament before the job he is remembered for in 1940. He was Home Secretary at thirty-five, then First Lord of the Admiralty at thirty-six, appointed Chancellor in 1924, followed by his wilderness years. He learned how to get there effectively by applying himself, failing, and learning from it, not from afar. That in itself is the very definition of the argument for Made.

Marcus Aurelius isn’t dissimilar. He was quaestor at eighteen, consul at nineteen, and again at twenty-four, then co-holder of the imperial powers from 147, running parts of the empire before running the entirety of it.

Napoleon told officers to read and re-read the campaigns of Alexander, Hannibal, Caesar, Gustavus, Turenne, Eugene and Frederick. He said it was “the only means of becoming a great captain.”

Bonaparte studying at Brienne. Illustration by Job, from Georges Montorgueil, Bonaparte (Boivin, 1908).

Thoughts

This seems a practical and sensible way to go about making a leader. Nevertheless, the need for the period of learning to have birthed a conviction is indicative of the necessity for (pre-)conditions that go beyond what can be learned. Just thinking about the importance of personality types, or Ray Dalio’s model of measuring who people are and recruiting, in part, according to their character attributes, brings forth an entire world of things beyond what is learned (Dalio, 2017).

Emperor Nero—whilst taught by Seneca, a master in Stoicism, the very philosophy Aurelius is known for today—still became the infamous Nero. I’m sure many of us can think of a person, or people, who are highly educated, but still choosing to go against their learned way.

Leaders are Born

The classic nature versus nurture debate has been researched and discussed many times throughout history. I think it is fair to say that the (current) consensus is that no-one is born finished, but that birth bestows on each person a set of characteristics or attributes, the combination of which makes each person more or less inclined to, or able in, certain things. So one of these things might be good leadership. My favourite, and the best-known psychological model for this, is The Big Five.

Peter Paul Rubens, Romulus and Remus, c. 1615 to 1616. The founders of Rome, sons of Mars, taken care of by the she-wolf, destined to found an empire.

Knowing what your people need

Trait Openness includes the facets of ideas and feelings out of which arises a curiosity about how others live and think. It is the strongest personality predictor of wanting to understand people unlike yourself. Trait Agreeableness includes the facets of warmth and tender-mindedness. Both these make others’ welfare feel more worth attending to. Trait Extraversion rewards people for social contact. Not necessarily for understanding them but for being amongst them more.

Research published in the Journal of Personality Assessment showed that social curiosity is a measurable and stable trait. It is, in other words, one’s appetite for knowing how others think, feel and behave (Renner, 2006). Perhaps the leader who knows his people best is the person who could not help wanting to.

One could see how a combination of Extraversion’s proclivity to be with others paired with the drive towards curiosity for others and that of valuing their welfare could result in a mixture that would make for someone who is naturally more interested than others in knowing what his people need.

One of the most replicated traits in personality psychology is the need for cognition, in other words, the enjoyment of effortful thinking (Cacioppo and Petty, 1982). Now, working out what a group needs, rather than what it says it wants, is effortful thinking. Combining our someone’s natural interest with the horsepower needed to work it out might result in someone born to be better in this domain.

The discipline to act on it

We could almost translate this subheading to one of the Big Five: Conscientiousness. It is the dimension that covers self-discipline, persistence, and follow-through. It is the strongest personality predictor of job performance across occupations, and of long-term outcomes from health to income.

In psychology there is the intention-behaviour gap, the distance between what people say they will do and what they do. Several hundred studies have shown that knowing what someone intends counts for ~25% of what is needed to predict whether they will act on it (Sheeran, 2002). Among the conscientious, however, several studies (most of them on exercise) showed that those higher in the trait turned intention into action more.

So if our hypothetical example from before would also score high in conscientiousness, we’d have someone who naturally seeks to understand others, values their welfare, enjoys thinking about it hard and has the self-discipline to act on his conviction (over the long term). It sounds like a solid foundation for a good father, teacher, coach or pastor to me.

Getting there effectively

Now whilst the first metric is in large part based on interest, and the second on one character trait, getting there effectively means being strategic, adaptable, wise, sharp, savvy, strong… the list goes on. Now I said in the introduction that I do not seek to define what makes someone a good leader, so I will not go and compare The Prince to the book of Proverbs, draw attributes and link them to the theories on personality. I trust the previous two sections are enough to present a fair substance for the born argument.

Leaders are Given

“How can all Achaeans be masters here in Troy?
Too many kings can ruin an army—mob rule!
Let there be one commander, one master only,
endowed by the son of crooked-minded Cronus
with kingly scepter and royal rights of custom:
whatever one man needs to lead his people well”

Odysseus speaking to the army.
Homer, Iliad 2.234 to 239 (trans. R. Fagles, 1990)

The main point for Given is that leadership is not primarily, that is firstly, learned, nor due to nature, but consciously given by the divine, both the ability and the station. That is not to disregard the influences of learning nor birth, but to say that the primary, and first, part is the divine bestowing, granting, gifting, allowing and so on.

It should be noted that the divine is a, literally, endless domain. I have studied (still am) Christianity and (ancient) Greco-Roman religion, so I will use examples I am confident in from those domains.

Knowing what your people need

The primary example here is King Solomon. Most people, or at least those who are Christian, Muslim or Jewish, about 4.5 billion of those alive, will be familiar with the king and his wisdom. For those who are not, in the Christian canon, the king asks God for an “understanding heart”, instead of might or wealth, and is given one.

Nicolas Poussin, The Judgement of Solomon, 1649

In Biblical Hebrew, the heart is the centre of intellect, inner reflection and decision-making. The ask of Solomon in Hebrew is lēv shōmēa (לֵ֤ב שֹׁמֵ֙עַ). Shōmēa is derived from shama (to hear or listen). It implies listening with intent, obedience and receptivity to God’s guidance. The Amplified Bible aims to spare modern people the research and bridges the gap by writing “understanding mind and a hearing heart”. So both an intellect and an ear for people. Two key leadership characteristics from the Born section.

Solomon, acting not out of self-seeking, humbly asks God for the ability to discern between good and evil and is granted it. In the same canon, Adam and Eve are punished for seizing that same power, without Solomon’s meekness and without asking.

The discipline to act on it

Whilst the ability, or the potential, is God-given, there remains the element of following through. Solomon is given a lēv shōmēa, but what does he do with it?

The Parable of the Talents addresses this second point perfectly. It’s one of the West’s most famous stories, the origin of the English word talent, and the origin of the Matthew effect, which I highlighted in my national development article. Three servants are given talents (gold coins). One receives 5, the other 2, the other 1. The first two servants trade and invest their talents, both doubling their investment and returning it. The third buries his talent in the ground (out of fear), and returns the same one talent. The first two are rewarded generously and trusted with more whilst the third is cast out and his talent given to the first. Over history, the West already turned Jesus’ parable into its literal meaning, so I won’t need to outline it here.

Getting there effectively

God gives, man must use what is given well, but does that guarantee a successful outcome? Where the book of Proverbs underlines that wise conduct will lead to better outcomes, the book of Ecclesiastes makes the point that wisdom is no guarantee of a better outcome. The book of Job explores the problem of unmerited suffering and challenges the simple human assumption that bad things only happen to bad people. When Job asks God for an explanation for the unmerited suffering, God answers him not with reason but by showing the complexity and vastness of the universe, too big for one mind to comprehend or make a statement such as what “should” happen to another.

Ending Remarks

So, which is it? Made, Born or Given? I’ll leave the decision to you.

The given must use the gift, because it is a loan “to whom much was given, of him much will be required” (Luke 12:48). The born must develop and sharpen their skills alongside their natural strengths, to develop their disposition into something tangible. The made need to study and apply what they learned against their other desires. None of the three results in a great leader on their own.

So, someone is following you, whether you’re an elder, parent, educator, pastor, manager, speaker or whatever it may be. Sharpen what you have.


Posted

in

by

on